Tonawanda News


February 25, 2012

HAYNES: Sizing up the Oscars

The big show is tonight and for the first time in my life, I have managed to catch every single movie nominated for the best picture award. And that’s no small feat since the Academy moved to allow up to 10 movies in this category two years ago, up from five in previous years.

That said, for the first time, I feel I can make a 100 percent informed decision on which flick I think should take home the little golden guy. Of course, who I think should win the award is often different from who the Academy selects, but that’s another story altogether. Without further ado, my thoughts on this year’s nine best picture nominees:

The Artist

Why it should win: “The Artist” was, simply put, a charming movie. Despite being a black and white silent picture — those who aren’t film aficionados could only complain more if it was foreign and more subtitle-dependent — it has found startling success, and much acclaim.

The film picked up a handful of awards at the Golden Globes last month: best comedy or musical, best actor in a comedy or musical, and best original score.

Why it shouldn’t win: It’s true, I fell in love with its charm and the actors’ charisma, but it didn’t blow me away. I felt the filmmakers didn’t make a clear case for George Valentin (Jean Dujardin). Are we supposed to hate him or love him? Is he a jerk or a lovable guy down on his luck? Should we be conflicted? I am, but not in the good way.

I'm betting the Academy ends up picking this one.

The Descendants

Why it should win: George Clooney’s had a big year and while I’ve never been a particular fan, this has to be one of my favorite films of his. It’s a good, solid story, and while we’re getting a little bit of the same ol’ George, the acting from newcomer Shailene Woodley was top-notch.

I could have watched the entire movie from her perspective, about her personal growth and her story, which leads me to ...

Why it shouldn’t win: Again, I’m not taken with Clooney, who plays, well, oscar ...

Continued from page 1c

a slightly depressed Clooney in this flick. Woodley was the most compelling part of this movie and that’s just not enough to earn it a golden statue.

Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close

Why it should win: I was amazed by how much I enjoyed this film. Nine times out of 10, I’m not going to go to the theater to watch a Tom Hanks or a Sandra Bullock movie, but this is neither. It’s a Thomas Horn movie — the kid who plays main character Oskar Schell.

Audiences are given to thinking Oskar might have something akin to Asperger’s, though we’re told he was inconclusively tested for the disorder. The kid is at once bright, incredibly social and often paralyzed with anxiety in his search for clues he believe his dead father has left for him.

Why it shouldn’t win: I honestly can’t find too many faults with the film and wouldn’t be upset if it took home the biggest award of the night, though it hasn’t gotten the buzz some of the other films have.

Some reviews have criticized the film for making light of the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks, but I find I don’t agree, because at its heart, the movie’s not really about that fateful day.

The Help

Why it should win: Another film I’m surprised I enjoyed it as much as I did. As much as one might think there’s nothing new to be said about race relations during the civil rights era, they’re wrong. Have you ever considered what it must have been like as a black woman to leave your children behind to go take care of a white baby day after day? Key acting from the likes of Viola Davis, Octavia Spencer and Jessica Chastain set this one apart.

Why it shouldn’t win: You need to be more than a pleasant surprise to rise to the top of the heap.


Why it should win: Martin Scorsese can direct a family film! The story — shockingly similar to the plot of “Extremely Loud” — and young actors are charming and sweet. It’s a movie that, at its heart is a love note to the magical world of cinema.

Why it shouldn’t win: There's actually a good chance this one gets the nod. The playing field is a little weak this year, why not take the opportunity to give the highest award to a family film, something that doesn't happen too often? Obviously, being a default winner, which in my estimation it would be, isn't enough to earn you an award.

Midnight in Paris

Why it should win: Woody Allen’s my pick as this year’s best picture. I absolutely adored Allen's return to form — "Scoop" and "Match Point" were a bit lackluster and while I enjoyed "Vicky Christina Barcelona," it was a departure from the angsty humor and charm I love so much about Allen's earlier works.

Why it shouldn't win: It should!


Why it should win: I applaud the film for making baseball almost interesting to me.

Why it shouldn't win: At best, "Moneyball" was a mediocre film with a pretty standard performance from Brad Pitt. Like Clooney, he tends to play himself in most of his flicks, so it takes something pretty spectacular to impress me. I really question the Academy's nod to this one.

The Tree of Life

Why it should win: It shouldn’t.

Why it shouldn’t win: I'm not sure opinions have been as divisive with any 2011 movie as they have been with this one. Some, like the Academy apparently, think the Terrence Malick-helmed film is the best thing to grace theater screens in ages. Others, like myself, think it's the most pretentious, overwrought film to ever come out of Hollywood. Unfortunately one of those spectacular performances by Pitt that I mentioned earlier gets lost in the ramblings and musings of what some are calling Malick's masterpiece. Too bad, because in its more lucid moments, the movie had some interesting things to say about parent/child relationships.

War Horse

Why it should win: Another film that surprised me. The initial trailers had me proclaiming to friends, "I have absolutely no desire to see a horse movie. Maybe if it was just about war, however. ..." Between "Extremely Loud," and "War Horse," it's a miracle I have any tears left. It's mostly an ensemble cast, so no one performance really sticks out, other than that of Joey the horse.

Why it shouldn't win: A good cry won't win you best picture, though I guess fan of "Titanic" would say otherwise.


In this amateur movie theater critic's estimation, it was a weak year for filmmaking, and even flicks that rose to the top for me (some that are perhaps easily written off as schlock, "The Girl With a Dragon Tattoo," "Bridesmaids" and "Harry Potter 7.2") were simply ignored.

Contact features editor Danielle Haynes at 693-1000, ext. 4116.

Text Only
  • BOOK NOOK: Books lists spooky side of Western New York Ask anyone in Western New York -- or anywhere at all, really -- about ghost stories, and I'll bet they have one for you.

    October 22, 2012

  • Solving a murder in a convent

    May 29, 2012

  • adamczyk, ed Stories from the neighborhood, and the concentration camp

    The person with a haunted past is a familiar and reliable trope in literature and film, and perhaps all of us have something about which to be haunted. A book by Lewiston resident Joseph Leary, “Klara,” sharply explains a story of past misdeeds in a well-written and evocative novel.

    May 21, 2012 1 Photo

  • Some tips for the fathers-to-be

    All of a sudden, I’m getting to feel like a bit of an ol’ pro at this fatherhood thing.

    May 21, 2012

  • Jill Keppeler Clueless and late to the garden party

    The more I get into this whole gardening thing, the more I realize how much I don’t know.

    It started not long after I finished my first “Clueless Gardener” column, when I walked into a store with the idea of making some gardening purchases. Seeds, I thought. Maybe some plants to transplant. But mainly, seeds. That’s kind of the point of a garden, right?

    May 21, 2012 1 Photo

  • crittercompanions2012.jpg Easy ways to enrich your pet's life and help the environment

    The day has come were my finely articulated words have been placed on the bottom of my bird cage to be soiled upon. Sure, it was funny when it was Joe Biden’s face or another writer’s work. But mine? So cruel. So proud.

    May 21, 2012 1 Photo

  • 120215 COPPER2.jpg All that glimmers

    Even during a drizzly February day, Gleam & Glimmer Stained Glass Studio is full of light.
    It shines through the stained glass pieces in the front of the Webster Street shop, glances off mosaics and jewelry and lands on the works in progress in the studio area, where students can learn to create their own multi-colored art.
    That’s exactly the way co-owner Suzanne Todaro likes it.

    March 8, 2012 1 Photo

  • Danielle Haynes mug HAYNES: Sizing up the Oscars

    The big show is tonight and for the first time in my life, I have managed to catch every single movie nominated for the best picture award.

    February 25, 2012 1 Photo

  • PopcornBar.jpg COLUMN: Make your popcorn red carpet-worthy

    Annual movie award shows are the perfect excuse for hosting a party.

    February 25, 2012 1 Photo

  • 120215 chocolate pie1.jpg HAYNES: Celebrating the Oscars with a little 'Help' in the kitchen

    February 25, 2012 1 Photo

Featured Ads
Seasonal Content
Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Front page
NDN Video
Raw: Japanese Soldiers Storm Beach in Exercises Raw: Weapons Fire Hits UN School in Gaza Raw: Rocket Launches Into Space With Cargo Ship Broken Water Main Floods UCLA Two Women Narrowly Avoid Being Hit by Train In Virginia, the Rise of a New Space Coast New Sanctions on Key Sectors of Russian Economy Crayola Announces Family Attraction in Orlando US Ready to Slap New Sanctions on Russia Kerry: Not Worried About Israeli Criticism Boater Rescued From Edge of Kentucky Dam Girl Struck by Plane on Florida Beach Dies Rodents Rampant in Gardens Around Louvre House to Vote on Slimmed-down Bill for Border Looming Demand Could Undercut Flight Safety Raw: 2 Shells Hit Fuel Tank at Gaza Power Plant Raw: Massive Explosions From Airstrikes in Gaza Giant Ketchup Bottle Water Tower Up for Sale Easier Nuclear Construction Promises Fall Short Kerry: Humanitarian Cease-fire Efforts Continue